Monday, February 8, 2010

Architecture of Doom


Peter Cohen's documentary, The Architecture of Doom, frames the rise of Nazism within the context of an aesthetic movement. Cohen compellingly argues that art was instrumental in defining Hitler's Nazi ideology. However, all of the evidence is circumstantial. His obsessive compulsion with ideal forms may have pre-dated his exposure to the Romantic artistic movement.

An avid follower of art and architecture, Hitler is shown visiting urban landmarks as the Paris Opera house, various museums, and the Greek ruins. The Aryan ideal is embodied through Hitler's affinity towards Romantic portraiture and classical Greek sculptures.

"Degenerate art" is assigned to Cubist distortion of the human form and its subject matter is further connected with physical deformity within mental institutions. The resulting Nazi emphasis on purity and cleanliness culminates through comparisons of Jews to vermin.

Ultimately, Cohen's presents a compelling, yet superficial argument. Clearly, there are parallels between the Nazi ideal and the artistic romanticism of form. It's a bit negligent and simplistic to assume the aesthetic movement as the sole instrument in defining Nazism. The documentary fails to rigorously examine Germany's political and historical context during Hitler's rise.

Friday, February 5, 2010

Architecture for New Science

AIA Center, NYC 02 February 2010

Rafael Moneo, with local architect, Davis Brody Bond is currently erecting a new Science Building at Columbia University on Broadway and 120th Street. Primary elements are the facade's clear anodized aluminum lateral bracing which may need to be checked out in various lighting conditions throughout the day. Additionally, the building incorporates an entry on Broadway that navigates three stories up to the campus level .


Perkins and Will has a science building up in the Bronx at Lehman College (CUNY). Sited just southwest of Vinoly's athletic building, the new building is a conservative and understated addition to the campus. The primary element is their admirable attempt towards the LEED platinum status. There's a potentially tacky constructed wetlands proposal for the courtyard. Perkins and Will spoke of a campus as its own ecosystem, which was accompanied by a very superficial understanding of ecology and ultimately was unconvincing.


SOM's Science Building is up at Deerfield Academy in Massachusetts. Its a curvy building with a lot of ramps and some brick. Unfortunately, the brick detracts from the lightness and elegance of the organic forms. The ramps and steps negotiate the the campus level with the athletic fields a few level down. The building clearly has a feel of dynamism and something to traverse and experience. Working with James Turell, SOM creates some compelling naturally lit interior spaces--elucidating an austere and almost "religious" quality.